As Meier observes, "fighting with ideas" would be a welcome substitute for fighting "with fists or guns or nasty sound bites" Students who become intellectuals are inventing a new identity as much as unearthing one that was already there.
McLaughlin finds versions of "vernacular theory" in such unlikely places as Elvis fan clubs, sitcom viewers, advertising copywriters, and Southern Christian antipornography activists. Moreover, there were few intellectuals who possessed the practical hands-on skills required to survive in the New World of North America, which absence from society lead to a deep-rooted, populist suspicion of men and women who Hidden intellectualism in "verbal virtuosity", rather than tangible, measurable products and services: The result was an odd curricular mixture that combined courses in which I memorized historical facts and literary quotations with courses in home economics, typing, and driver education.
Such memory work might have been valuable had there been some larger context of issues or problems to give it point and meaning, but there rarely was. In my own case, the fascination with being tough played itself out in amicable disputes with friends, but in different circumstances it might have taken a more aggressively defiant and machismo form.
It was an era, as Richard Hofstadter would document in his Anti-intellectualism Hidden intellectualism American Life, when intellect was notoriously undervalued and scorned.
The cultural re-organization of Cambodian society, by the dictator Pol Potcreated a government which tried to re-make its society anti-intellectual in what became known as Democratic Kampuchea —a de-industrialized, agricultural country.
With Holden and Huck against us, Crandus and I decided that, though our goal was to persuade his eleventh graders that becoming an intellectual might be a good thing, the best tactic would be not to try to convert them but to spark a classroom debate on the pros and cons of intellectualism and its forms of talk, a debate that would get them to wrestle with their contradictions and ambivalences over the issue.
Bridging this gulf is not a matter of turning "them" into miniversions of "us," or of asking students to give up their language in favor of our academic discourse.
Hence the Fascist rejection of materialist logicbecause it relies upon a priori principles improperly counter-changed with a posteriori ones that are irrelevant to the matter-in-hand in deciding whether or not to act. Then, too, why try to turn students into clones of academics and intellectuals?
Furthermore, these texts often dramatize the issue of hidden intellectualism by focusing reflexively on language. Most of the white population of colonial America arrived as indentured servants and the black population as slaves. Hence, he decided to un-tap his hidden intellectualism linked to extracurricular activities like sports Graff, The Rise of Elvis Presley.
The Catcher in the Rye. Crandus then posed the question of intellectualism: Yet consumption itself generates much youthful arguing, and if some groups are culturally more prone to argumentation than others, everyone has a stake in learning to use argument to express and defend his or her interests.
When I declared my change of loyalty to the boys and men at the local package store where I hung out, they were contemptuous and scornful. Furthermore, sports arguments, debates, and analyses made you part of a community, not just of your friends but of the national public culture. The stakes are certainly raised when these "nonacademic concerns" come to include drug trafficking, gang-banging, and other criminal behavior.
I suspect we underrate the role of sports in the elementary literacy training of future intellectuals not necessarily only male ones either. Crandus and I were aware, however, that this view of the legitimacy and power of intellectual language set us against Huck and Holden themselves and presumably Twain and Salingerwhose distinctively vernacular language dramatizes their rejection of the hypocritical and inauthentic ways of conventional society and the rigidified forms of academic intellectualism.
Anti-intellectualism in American Life. In presenting academically successful students as social failures, an undesirable social status for the average young man and young woman, corporate media established to the U.
In that manner, the intellectuals of a society intervene and participate in social arenas of which they might not possess expert knowledge, and so unduly influence the formulation and realization of public policy.
Sometimes one or another party to an agreement has little choice in the matter: To emerge as critical theory, street smarts have to undergo transformation.
Since school defined itself as everything that supposedly debased American popular culture was not, sports and games could only be an escape from--and an antidote to--schooling and intellect.
The Rise of Elvis Presley. I went on to say, however, that, despite T. Is it possible to blend both into a single discourse? Graff also argues that intellectualism is good, and that schools ought to encourage learners to read, think critically and write about their fields of personal interests like fashion, music or cars Dana, On the one hand, mass communications greatly expand the sheer volume of information available for public consumption.
His areas of oversight include curricular innovation, teacher training, and freshman education and writing. These individuals may be said to possess a form of intellectualism that is concealed.
Some, of course, will question whether any such transformation should be attempted.The Chosen: The Hidden History of Admission and Exclusion at Harvard, Yale, and Princeton [Jerome Karabel] on palmolive2day.com *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers.
A landmark, revelatory history of admissions from to today—and how it shaped a nation The competition for a spot in the Ivy League—widely considered the ticket to success—is fierce and getting fiercer.
My Hidden Intellectualism In one sense, then, it would be hard to imagine a childhood more thoroughly anti-intellectual than mine. Yet in retrospect I see that I and the s themselves were not simply hostile toward intellectualism, but divided and ambivalent. Title: Hidden Intellectualism.
Author: matt Created Date: 12/9/ PM. I believe this essay "Hidden Intellectualism," by Gerald Graff is a very persuasive argument. It seems to be a sound, strong argument for the authors point. he not only lists exactly what he is talking about, but also what could help other; specifically how street smarts can very well be more intellectual than book smarts.
¶ 1 Leave a comment on paragraph 1 2 Hidden Intellectualism ¶ 2 Leave a comment on paragraph 2 0 Pedagogy () ¶ 3 Leave a comment on paragraph 3 0 Gerald Graff ¶ 4 Leave a comment on paragraph 4 0 ¶ 5 Leave a comment on paragraph 5 7 In an arresting memoir “of a Pentecostal boyhood” that appeared in in the Voice Literary Supplement, Michael Warner describes his.
In the essay “Hidden Intellectualism”, Gerald Graff argues that there is a possibility of some form of hidden intellectualism besides the traditional academic intellectualism.Download